|Year : 2019 | Volume
| Issue : 1 | Page : 28-32
Personality traits of young men with different diplotypes
Pavel N Ermakov1, Elena V Vorobyeva2, Ekaterina M Kovsh1, Irina V Abakumova3, Olga D Fedotova4, Marina P Aralova1, Wladimir W Latun5, Lubov Ya Horonko6
1 Department of Psychophysiology and Clinical Psychology, Academy of Psychology and Educational Sciences, Southern Federal University, Rostov-on-Don, Russia
2 Department of Psychophysiology and Clinical Psychology, Faculty of Psychology, Pedagogy and Defectology, Don State Technical University, Rostov-on-Don, Russia
3 Department of General and Counselling Psychology, Faculty of Psychology, Pedagogy and Defectology, Don State Technical University, Rostov-on-Don, Russia
4 Department of Primary Education, Faculty of Psychology, Pedagogy and Defectology, Don State Technical University, Rostov-on-Don, Russia
5 Department of Social-Economic Geography and Nature Management, Institute for Earth Sciences, Southern Federal University, Rostov-on-Don, Russia
6 Department Education and Pedagogical Sciences, Academy of Psychology and Pedagogy, Southern Federal University, Rostov-on-Don, Russia
|Date of Web Publication||10-Jun-2019|
Prof. Elena V Vorobyeva
Department of Psychophysiology and Clinical Psychology, Faculty of Psychology, Pedagogy and Defectology, Don State Technical University, 1 Gagarin sq., Rostov-on-Don, 344000
Source of Support: None, Conflict of Interest: None
Background: Historically in psychogenetic research the attention has been paid to describing personality traits of the carriers of some sole genotypes; but in this work the characteristic traits of carriers of catecholaminergic system MAOA and COMT genes' genotypes different combinations are presented. Methods: A psychodiagnostic toolkit included 7 types of inventories. Genotyping was conducted with the help of DNA extraction from the buccal epithelium cells with subsequent PCR diagnostics and 3 types of statistical processing. Results: It was shown that carriers of a highly active diplotype have the lowest level of aggressiveness and are inclined to cooperate in the conflict; carriers of the highly active genotype MAOA in combination with the heterozygous genotype COMT have an average level of aggressiveness and high rates of emotional lability; carriers of low-level MAOA in combination with heterozygous genotype COMT have the highest rates of motivation to achieve success and verbal aggression; carriers of low-level MAOA and highly active COMT are emotionally labile and non-aggressive. Conclusion: We conclude that male carriers of a low-active diplotype have the highest level of aggressiveness and disposition to addictive behavior, which may indicate the association of this diplotype in a sample of young Russian men with social disadaptation.
Keywords: Diplotypes, genotype, MAOA-uVNTR, neurotransmitter system genes, polymorphic loci, Val158Met COMT, young men
|How to cite this article:|
Ermakov PN, Vorobyeva EV, Kovsh EM, Abakumova IV, Fedotova OD, Aralova MP, Latun WW, Horonko LY. Personality traits of young men with different diplotypes. Acta Med Int 2019;6:28-32
| Introduction|| |
The study of relationship of diplotypes (combinations of genotypes at different polymorphic gene loci) with psychological characteristics of people belonging to different groups is the level of data analysis following the study of the links of individual single-nucleotide polymorphisms with different personal characteristics. Today, a full analysis of the genome is available, but for a large volume of analyzed information, significant details often get lost. In view of the latter, the analysis of combinations of several genes responsible for certain neurochemical transformations and their manifestation in specific psychological characteristics is still relevant.
The MAOA and COMT genes are associated with the activity of enzymes that break down neurotransmitters in synaptic space with catecholaminergic neurotransmission and therefore are indirectly related to the duration and intensity of the ongoing emotions, which in their turn may impose an imprint on stable personal characteristics and features of human behavior. Previously, we described the results obtained in the study of relationship of individual genes with the psychological characteristics of men and women;,, this article is devoted to the analysis of the connection of a combination of genotypes at the polymorphic loci Val158Met of the COMT gene and the uVNTR gene of MAOA with the psychological characteristics of men. This type of analysis can allow us to identify specific features of the interaction of genes, reflected in psychological signs.
As the subject of the study, we chose the genes of the neurotransmitter systems MAOA – the monoamine oxidase Type A gene; minisatellite VNTR sequences in the promoter region of the gene; men may have high- (H; 4, 4.5, and 3.5 repetitions) and low-activity (L; 2 and 3 repetitions) genotypes- and COMT-catechol-O-methyltransferase gene; GenBank AY341246 sequence, mutation 23753G>A Val158Met, rs-code rs4680; and possible genotypes: homozygous for allele G (GG; Val/Val), heterozygous (GA; Val/Met), and homozygous for allele A (AA; Met/Met).
As it is known, the MAOA gene is a candidate gene of aggressive behavior. Numerous studies support this postulate. Various polymorphisms of the MAOA gene are also associated with a propensity to suicidal behavior, which in general probably indicates the role of dysfunction of monoaminergic transmission in the formation of various nonadaptive behavioral features. In recent years, there have been reports of a link with the level of aggressiveness and other personality traits (high levels of anxiety, neuroticism, etc.) of polymorphism Val158Met of COMT gene.,
Hypothesis about interaction of factors of heredity and environment (the diathesis–stress hypothesis) in the predisposition to high aggressiveness has become widespread in the genetics of behavior, and it is confirmed by many researchers., In a number of experiments, attempts have been made to find associations between genotypes of the MAOA and COMT genes and psychological characteristics, taking into account environmental influences. Thus, Gottschalk and Domschke show the relationship between the minor genotype of the gene COMT (AA) and “harm avoidance,” “anticipatory worry,” and “fear of uncertainty” in the sample of women, while MAOA-H in the sample of adolescents is associated with higher rates of generalized anxiety.
Recently, hypothesis of differential susceptibility to different parenting conditions of carriers of different genotypes has become more relevant. In his work, Baumann et al. show that carriers of low-activity genotypes of MAOA and COMT, who have experience of violence, are prone to manifesting reactive aggression, the level of which is lower among carriers of these genotypes with a favorable parenting experience. Thus, the differences in the features of gene–environment interactions and their influence on the severity of various forms of aggression are shown. The article also notes that the presence of early experience of violence in carriers of low-activity genotypes of MAOA and SOMT of men is associated with a high risk of developing anxiety disorders. Data on the interaction of factors “level of aggressiveness” and “violence in childhood” are confirmed by many researchers for different ethnic groups. However, in a number of studies, it is noted that the increase in crime is more affected by distal stress (violence in childhood) and the presence of proximal stress (violence in adulthood) is a factor that enhances this relationship. The hypothesis of differentiated susceptibility is also confirmed in the study by Zhang et al., which shows association of low-activity genotypes MAOA (T941G) and COMT (Val158Met) with reactive aggression of Chinese teenagers with low-positive parenting.
MAOA and COMT are genes of the catecholaminergic system, they can influence neurotransmitter metabolism in combination. The today existing results of studies on the analysis of associations of diplotypes MAOA and COMT with different psychological characteristics mainly have a clinical focus and are performed in the study of genetic correlates of various mental illnesses such as generalized anxiety disorder, depression, and schizophrenia; part of the research is devoted to the study of the psychological experience of pain. Thus, in a sample of women, a relationship was shown between a low-activity IAAA L + SOMT AA diplotype and a high risk of developing a clinical, as well as postpartum depression.
However, at the present stage, there is not enough research describing associations of diplotypes of these genes with aggressiveness and other personal characteristics in the sample of men. In addition, in the scientific literature, there is no detailed description of the psychological characteristics of carriers of different genotypes combinations, which is also of great interest. The factors listed above have determined the choice of the purpose and subject of this study.
| Methods|| |
The purpose of this study is to study personality characteristics of men who are carriers of various diplotypes of polymorphic loci COMT Val158Met and MAOA-uVNTR.
Hypothesis of the study
Carriers of different diplotypes at polymorphic loci Val158Met of gene COMT and uVNTR of gene MAOA have significant differences in the severity of such psychological characteristics as the level and forms of aggression (including socially approved and legitimized) and hostility, propensity to deviant behavior, strategies of behavior in a conflict, the level of motivation to achieve success, the formal dynamic properties of individuality, the level of emotional lability, depressiveness, and suspicion.
The sample consisted of 76 Russian men, including 13 carriers of diplotype MAOA-H + COMT GG, 15 carriers of MAOA-H + COMT GA, 12 carriers of MAOA-H + COMT AA, 12 carriers of MAOA-L + COMT GG, 12 carriers of MAOA-L + COMT GA, and 12 carriers of MAOA-L + COMT AA.
In the course of the study, the following psychodiagnostic toolkit was used: the multidisciplinary personality methodology in adaptation of Berezin et al., a questionnaire of formal-dynamic properties of individuality by Rusalov, Thomas test (in adaptation of Grishina), A. Mehrabian test questionnaire for measuring achievement of motivation (in adaptation of Magomed-Eminov), and Buss–Durkee Hostility Inventory adapted by Osnitsky, 1998, the “LA-44” test for determining the level and types of legitimized (socially approved) aggression, and the technique of diagnosing a person's propensity for deviant behavior.
To determine genotypes, a method was used to isolate DNA from buccal epithelium cells followed by polymerase chain reaction diagnostics (SFU Center for Collective Use “High Technologies,” Russia, Rostov-on-Don).
The statistical processing was done using analysis of variances, post hoc Fisher analysis, and least significant difference test, P ≤ 0.05.
| Results|| |
The results obtained in the course of the study make it possible to judge the following peculiarities of the relationships between the diplomats of the MAOA and COMT genes with psychological characteristics of men.
According to the results obtained, carries of a highly active diplotype (MAOA-H + COMT GG) have a low level of verbal aggression (average: 54.7 points, P = 0.02), aggressive motivation [average: 17.8 points, P = 0.007; [Figure 1] and [Figure 2]; P ≤ 0.05], as well as legitimized aggression (average 78 points, P = 0.04) and are inclined to choose cooperation strategies in the conflict (average 6.4 points, P = 0.42) and avoidance (compare the results of 6.1 points, P = 0.28). The described features characterize this group as the most nonaggressive in the sample under study.
|Figure 1: The level of aggressiveness in men with several diplotypes in polymorphic loci Val158Met of the COMT gene and uVNTR of the MAOA gene (post hoc Fisher analysis, least significant difference test). *P ≤ 0.05|
Click here to view
|Figure 2: The integral level of the legitimized aggression in men with several diplotypes in polymorphic loci Val158Met of the COMT gene and uVNTR of the MAOA gene (post hoc Fisher analysis, least significant difference test). *P ≤ 0.01|
Click here to view
According to the data received, the carriers of the diplotype MAOA-H + COMT GA do not tend to avoid conflicts (average: 4.3 points, P = 0.28), have a low index of legitimized aggression (average: 76 points, P = 0.04, [Figure 1] and [Figure 2]; P ≤ 0.01), high indices of general emotionality (average: 86.8 points, P = 0.01) and emotional lability. They are not inclined to aggression and violence. In general, this group of men is characterized by high sensitivity, insecurity, anxiety in various spheres of activity and communication, as well as emotional instability. In this case, the level of aggression in men of this group is in mean values; the most pronounced form of aggression is verbal.
Carriers of the diplotype MAOA-L + COMT GA have a significantly higher level of achievement of motivation (average: 155.3 points), compared to MAOA-H + COMT AA carriers [compare: 126.2 b., [Figure 3]; P = 0.04]. At the same time, they have a high level of verbal aggression [compare: 80, P = 0.02].
|Figure 3: The level of achievement motivation in men with several diplotypes in polymorphic loci Val158Met of the COMT gene and uVNTR of the MAOA gene (post hoc Fisher analysis, least significant difference test). *P ≤ 0.01|
Click here to view
Male carriers of the combination MAOA-L + COMT GG have the highest indicators of emotional lability (average: 66.7 points, P = 0.02) and the lowest indices of aggression (average: 5.3 points, P = 0.02) and general emotionality (average: 54.7 points, P = 0.01). Their level of aggressive motivation is the lowest (average: 15.7 points, P = 0.007) and are not inclined to addictive behaviour (average: 4 points, P = 0.001) and delinquent behavior (average: 12 points, P = 0.02; [Figure 4]).
|Figure 4: Manifestation of the deviant behavior types in men with several diplotypes in polymorphic loci Val158Met of the COMT gene and uVNTR of the MAOA gene (post hoc Fisher analysis, least significant difference test). *P ≤ 0.01|
Click here to view
Let's pay attention to the fact that the carriers of the genotype COMT AA in combination with MAOA-H and MAOA-L have the highest rates on the scale of verbal aggression in the studied sample (average: 74.8 points and 104.5 points, respectively, P = 0.08).
Carriers of the low-activity diplotype MAOA-L + COMT AA have a number of psychological characteristics that distinguish them from other participants of the study. They have high rates on the scales of physical, verbal, and socially approved aggression, a high aggression index and the level of aggressive motivation, propensity to addictions (average: 16.5 points, P = 0.001) and delinquent behavior (average: 12 points, P = 0.001), compared to carriers of the combination MAOA-L with COMT GG (average: 3.3 points, P = 0.02), and also to the implementation of aggression and violence in direct behavior ([Figure 4], P ≤ 0.01). The described features characterize this group as the most aggressive one among carriers of different diplotypes at polymorphic loci VAL158MET of the COMT gene and uVNTR of the MAOA gene.
| Discussion|| |
The neuronal and biochemical mechanisms underlying these associations are still unknown, but in our opinion, the assumption of a link between the low-activity genotypes MAOA and COMT with a violation of regulation of the limbic system structures activity by the prefrontal cortex, that is, with a disturbance in the regulation of emotions.,
It is necessary to take into account the fact that behavior is a complex feature that involves various factors. Undoubtedly, it is promising to analyze genome modifications that do not affect the DNA sequence but which have an effect on gene activity supergene (epigenetic) factors, as well as environmental factors affecting manifestation of psychological characteristics of carriers of different genotypes. In addition to external factors, there are factors of the internal environment that also influence the behavior and psychological characteristics of a person. These include the hormonal background, the level of which is also determined by genetic and environmental influences (most often there are studies in which aggressive behavior is associated with sex hormones, testosterone, and estradiol). A complex study of these parameters will create a clearer picture of the studied phenomena. Interesting is also the study of gene-by-stress and gene-by-alcohol interactions. The genome-wide association study genome analysis method is widely used to reveal the data of role of synaptic plasticity and characteristics of neurodevelopment in the prediction of aggressiveness and other psychological characteristics.
| Conclusion|| |
Based on the obtained results, we can conclude that the genetic predictor of high aggressiveness of men is a combination of low-activity genotypes MAOA and COMT. Their presence individually increases the level of various types of aggression: MAOA-L is probably more associated with an increase in aggressiveness level as a personality trait, as well as with paranoid, pessimistic and high levels of legitimate violence. The genotype of COMT AA of men is more associated with the tendency to different forms of deviation. In combination, the described genotypes enhance each other's action.
Personal characteristics of carriers of low-active forms of MAOA and COMT genes, according to the obtained data, are manifested in the presence of destructive nature, which can contribute to the social disadaptation of the represented group of men. Low-active diplotype carriers tend to commit offenses and attempt to solve problems through escape from reality through the use of psychoactive substances or development of nonchemical addictions, as well as the approval of manifestations of aggression and violence in society. The described behavioral strategies can be called “dopamine addiction.” To get new unusual impressions and to avoid collisions with a frightening reality, people who have a similar genotype resort to the use of auxiliary means that can raise the level of neurotransmitters and correct the mood background, get rid of anxiety and fear.
Due to the relation of the MAOA and COMT genes in the monoamine neurotransmitters (dopamine, serotonin, and norepinephrine) in synaptic space, the reverse acquisition of neurotransmitters of carriers of different diplotypes occurs at different rates, which may affect duration of the course of emotional reactions, their intensity, and can be associated with stable emotional reactions and state (mood). Carriers of low-active diplotypes have a slower reverse capture of neurotransmitters, which manifests itself in more prolonged and intense emotional reactions. The described mechanism can explain the high level of aggressiveness, pessimism, and paranoid nature of members of this group.
The presence of highly active alleles of the G gene of COMT and H gene of MAOA gene of men is probably associated with an average, adaptive level of aggressiveness, which may be related to the average duration of how long monoamines are in synaptic space. The presence of H in the diplotype MAOA probably alleviates the predisposition to high aggressiveness embedded in allele A of the COMT gene; the GG genotype in combination with MAOA-L probably reduces the level of propensity to aggression inherent in the latter.
Emotional reactions of men with highly active diplotype probably proceed and replace each other more quickly, which may explain the lower level of aggressiveness of members of this group (it is important to take into account that at the physiological level ability to quickly calm down may occur, i.e., replacement of aggressive state with a balanced one).
Financial support and sponsorship
This investigation has been carried out with financial support from the Russian Science Foundation (project No. 213.01-03/2016-4, agreement No. 16-18-10222).
Conflicts of interest
There are no conflicts of interest.
| References|| |
Canli T, editor. The Oxford Handbook of Molecular Psychology. Oxford: Oxford University Press; 2015.
Kovsh EM, Ermakov PN, Vorobyeva EV. The Association of the polymorphic marker val158met of gene comt with the level of aggressiveness and strategies of behavior in conflict among girls 18-24 years old. North Caucasian Psychol Bull 2015;3:15-21.
Kovsh EM, Skirtach IA, Bunyaeva MV. Psychological features of aggression and hostility of the youth of Southern Russia. Russ Psychol J 2015;12:91-103.
Bunyaeva MV, Kovsh EM, Skirtach IA, Ilyin AB. The reflection of the combination of genotypes of polymorphic loci of COMT val158met and MAOA.uvNTR in psychological features of girls. Russ Psychol J 2016;13:218.31. doi: 10.21702/rpj.2016.4.13.
Alfmova MV, Trubnikov VI. Psychogenetic basis of aggressiveness. Approaches Psychol 2000;6:112-3.
Balestri M, Calati R, Serretti A, Hartmann AM, Konte B, Friedl M, et al.
Maoa and maob polymorphisms and personality traits in suicide attempters and healthy controls: A preliminary study. Psychiatry Res 2017;249:212-7.
Grant JE, Leppink EW, Redden SA, Odlaug BL, Chamberlain SR. COMT genotype, gambling activity, and cognition. J Psychiatr Res 2015;68:371-6.
Kotyuk E, Duchek J, Head D, Szekely A, Goate AM, Balota DA, et al.
A genetic variant (COMT) coding dopaminergic activity predicts personality traits in healthy elderly. Pers Individ Dif 2015;82:61-6.
Smeijers D, Bulten E, Franke B, Buitelaar J, Verkes RJ. Associations of multiple trauma types and MAOA with severe aggressive behavior and MAOA effects on training outcome. Eur Neuropsychopharmacol 2017. pii: S0924-977X(17)30293-6.
Gallardo-Pujol D, Andrés-Pueyo A, Maydeu-Olivares A. MAOA genotype, social exclusion and aggression: An experimental test of a gene-environment interaction. Genes Brain Behav 2013;12:140-5.
Gottschalk MG, Domschke K. Genetics of generalized anxiety disorder and related traits. Dialogues Clin Neurosci 2017;19:159-68.
Baumann C, Klauke B, Weber H, Domschke K, Zwanzger P, Pauli P, et al.
The interaction of early life experiences with COMT val158met affects anxiety sensitivity. Genes Brain Behav 2013;12:821-9.
Galán CA, Choe DE, Forbes EE, Shaw DS. The interaction between monoamine oxidase A and punitive discipline in the development of antisocial behavior: Mediation by maladaptive social information processing. Dev Psychopathol 2017;29:1235-52.
Wells J, Armstrong T, Boisvert D, Lewis R, Gangitano D. Stress, genes, and generalizability across gender: Effects of MAOA and stress sensitivity on crime and delinquency. Criminology 2017;55:548-74.
Zhang W, Cao C, Wang M, Ji L, Cao Y. Monoamine oxidase A (MAOA) and catechol-O-methyltransferase (COMT) gene polymorphisms interact with maternal parenting in association with adolescent reactive aggression but not proactive aggression: Evidence of differential susceptibility. J Youth Adolesc 2016;45:812-29.
George SZ, Wallace MR, Wright TW, Moser MW, Greenfield WH 3rd
, Sack BK, et al.
Evidence for a biopsychosocial influence on shoulder pain: Pain catastrophizing and catechol-O-methyltransferase (COMT) diplotype predict clinical pain ratings. Pain 2008;136:53-61.
Couto TC, Brancaglion MY, Alvim-Soares A, Moreira L, Garcia FD, Nicolato R, et al.
Postpartum depression: A systematic review of the genetics involved. World J Psychiatry 2015;5:103-11.
Doornbos B, Dijck-Brouwer DA, Kema IP, Tanke MA, van Goor SA, Muskiet FA, et al.
The development of peripartum depressive symptoms is associated with gene polymorphisms of MAOA, 5-HTT and COMT. Prog Neuropsychopharmacol Biol Psychiatry 2009;33:1250-4.
Berezin FB, Miroshnikov MP, Sokolova ED. Method of Multilateral Study of Personality. Moscow: Berezin Felix Borisovich; 2011.
Rusalov VM. The Questionnaire of the Formal-Dynamic Properties of Individuality: Methodical Manual. Moscow; RAS Publishing. House; 1997.
Grishina NV. Psychology of Conflict. St. Peterburg: Piter; 2008.
Magomed-Jeminov MS. Achievement Motivation: Structure and Mechanisms. Ph.D Abstract Thesis. Moscow: Lomonosov MSU; 1987.
Hvan AA, Zajcev Ju A, Kuznecova Ju A. The experience of standardizing the questionnaire of measuring aggressiveness and hostile reactions of A. Buss and A. Durkee. Psychol Diagn 2008;1:35-58.
Enikolopov SN, Cibul'skij NP. The study of relationship between legitimization of violence and tendency to aggressive behavior. Psychol Sci Educ 2008;1:90-8.
Oryol AN. The Technique of Diagnostics of Tendency to Deviant Behavior: Guide. Yaroslavl: NPTs Psihhodiagnostika; 1999.
Eisner P, Klasen M, Wolf D, Zerres K, Eggermann T, Eisert A, et al.
Cortico-limbic connectivity in MAOA-L carriers is vulnerable to acute tryptophan depletion. Hum Brain Mapp 2017;38:1622-35.
Kovsh EM. Psychological and Psychophysiological Features of Men and Women, Carriers of Various Polymorphic Loci of MAOA and COMT Genes with Different Levels of Aggressiveness. PhD Dissertation. Rostov-on-Don: SFU; 2016.
Wagels L, Votinov M, Radke S, Clemens B, Montag C, Jung S, et al.
Blunted insula activation reflects increased risk and reward seeking as an interaction of testosterone administration and the MAOA polymorphism. Hum Brain Mapp 2017;38:4574-93.
Fernàndez-Castillo N, Cormand B. Aggressive behavior in humans: Genes and pathways identified through association studies. Am J Med Genet B Neuropsychiatr Genet 2016;171:676-96.
[Figure 1], [Figure 2], [Figure 3], [Figure 4]